Forwards
Gagner -115
RNH -45
Granlund -39
Sheahan -37
Kassian -35
Chiasson -27
Khaira -20
Draisaitl -17
Total Negative = -339
McDavid +49
Neal +30
Total Positive = +79
Offense Total = -260

Defense
Klefbom -47
Nurse -5
Russell -5
Total Negative = -57
Benning +24
Larsson +16
Total Positive = +40
Defense Total = -17
Overall Total = -277

These numbers don't give me much confidence in Holland and Tippett.